Every once in a while this comes up. I appreciate it. Shows me that people care.
Some random comments:
1. Any ratings system will be abused. No matter how you implement it. No one will ever be satisfied.
2. A lot of votes are not included in the ranking. There's a lot of code to decide which ones do. This is not visible anywhere. That's all I'm going to say about it.
3. The current top 100 is what YOU make of it. The list itself is not something you should agree or disagree with. It's a statistical work of art but it's not meant to be YOUR list op top games. It's a starting point to dive deeper into.
4. Read. The. Rating. Comments.
5. A concept for a completely new Pinside ranking is aging in the barrels. Once I pour it in the glass that is Pinside, it will be... awesome... Yet still a lot of people will probably dislike it. You can never please everybody.
6. Should Star Wars be #2? Hell no. (sorry Steve)