I've only owned 20 pins and 6 have been modern Sterns. I've played just about everything.
last Stern I purchased NIB was GOT and that ended up leaving after about a year (good pin though). The only "keeper" Stern for me has been IMVE. Had LOTR for eight years but it became way too much of a grind and was a horrible multiplayer game.
I really wanted to love GB...didn't. I really, really wanted to love SW...didn't. Not impressed with what I've been seeing lately from Stern. My money went to Alien instead...and I'll let you know how that pans out.
POTC (JJP) is the best JJP game I've seen so far...really impressed with that one. No question they are building higher quality games...but you're paying for it also.
Spooky...I like Charlie and love what he's been able to accomplish in this very tough hobby of ours. I thought AMH was fun but just not a theme I was into at all. TNA looks awesome to me and I hope they sell a ton of them.