I realize that I'm breaking the rules but I have a '49 K. C. Jones that's a lot of fun. It even has a random ball-save down the middle. Keeper.
Just before that I owned a '53 Quintette which has a lot of pretty girls and several goals to shoot for. The 5 gobble holes were difficult to avoid. Tough game.
I also owned a '53 Guys Dolls and the gameplay stunk. Ridiculous "Six High Powered Pop-up Posts". Hated it.
Admittedly, I haven't had a great deal of exposure to woodrails but I have to own one.