I would go with any of those except for Avengers. That's not Stern's best game. You'd also want to try Iron Man if you haven't played it and see if you like it. It's a tough game sometimes, so it's not for everyone. WOZ and LOTR are great (I own them), but I haven't played The Hobbit yet. Good luck - isn't it a wonderful life when you're greatest concern is what your third pin is going to be?

This thread is making me so happy. Just about everybody is naming WOZ and LOTR as the two pins for him to get...and they're the two that I currently own. I've been struggling with what to get as my third pin while I wait for my Hobbit. Tron? AC/DC? Congo? POTC? But the more I look and the more I think about it, I should probably just hold for now and be happy with what I've got. I think anything else might be a letdown...and I can always play those other games at Modern Pinball, etc. That being said, I REALLY don't want to wait for Hobbit to have a third machine!!!