I paid 1000 for mine about 5 yrs ago. Was likely in better shape than the one you describe. Cabinet had very little fade. Little wear around the KISS inserts in the middle of the PF, and some cupped inserts. Spend about 150 in board work and had pretty decent looking and 100% playing machine. Really not a bad pin IMO. I'm biased because I like KISS though. I'd like another some day when room permits. I wouldn't offer much, if any over 2k on this one with the info you shared....just my .02

That's typical wear for a KISS playfield. Nothing unusual about it. It is a standard wood playfield..