Well gents, BIG progress, we are ALMOST there...
First off, thanks to all of you, and doubly so to Steve, for all the great guidance and for pushing me WELL beyond my comfort zone. I never thought I'd be able to do as much of this on my own as I have. Thanks for that. BT, awesome schematic, thanks for adding it!
So, the other night I removed the switches, brake, and then the entire pitching mech. I removed the cam, cleaned all of the old hardened original grease that had been left on there (as well as the new grease that I mistakenly added), I found one hinge that was frozen with old grease (see pic, red arrow) which is clean and smooth now. Everything came out great and it looks fantastic. Before and After Pics below for Pinside posterity.
I reassembled the Mech, and put everything back together, re-tensioned the spring, added the balls... and LO and BEHOLD! It pitched!! BUT... after pitching 4 or 5 balls... it started sticking. If I move the cam, it will unstick and complete the pitch, and will pitch again one more time before sticking again.
So, tonight I'm going to pull it apart again and try to figure out what is causing it to stick, but in the meantime if anyone has suggestions, please feel free. With any luck, I'll figure out what it is and I'll start swingin for the bleachers!! So close...
VIDEO of motor sticking: https://photos.app.goo.gl/Bd9WA1MnGoPh1fU87
Cam Before (resized).jpgcam after (resized).jpgspring before (resized).jpgspring after (resized).jpgstuck1 (resized).pngassembeled 1 (resized).jpgassembeled 2 (resized).jpg