Since you're asking for price policing... yes, you're asking too much. There are only a couple of iconic and popular titles from this era that *might* draw interest at $750. There's just not much interest in this era, and only a handful of us that actually collect the games. Even then, most are interested in particular titles or innovative game features. This game doesn't have the game features, nor any particular aesthetic appeal.

Most of the generic machines of this era that actually sell seem to go between $100 and $250.

I would say $200-$400 if it’s in great shape cosmetically. I would agree with your thought that eBay (Or Craigslist) might be a better venue.

At the History Of Pinball Booth at TPF I normally price standard table tops between 200 and 400. I sold a Jiggers Jr Last year for $300

If thats a Sr with Legs. I would price that at $400 - $550 depending on the crowd at the booth.

--Jeff