Critiques first:
The music is EXCELLENT, but repetitive. With long ball times it can be droning. Luckily there's different music during modes.
The sound quality between the different voices and the music feels off... almost as if they were recorded using different methods. The theme song is booming and Dredd sounds awesome, but the modes almost sound like they were recorded using a completely different (and worse) technology.
The Cabinet art is boring. I've seen an alternate with black instead of blue, which looks a little bit better, but would LOVE full comic art similar to the back glass.
Once you beat the wizard mode and the final boss, it's just victory lap jackpots after that. Not many games hold my immediate interest after I "beat" them (unless in tourny play), so at this point it's likely I'd just let them drain and go play another game.
The pros:
The backglass art, playfield art, and topper are all beautiful.
This game is LOADED with stuff to do. Tons of shots, tons of modes and mini modes, a "super" multiball that you can start with, and the Dredd callouts for each shot/task are excellent. You can shoot never ending combos on this thing.
As a fan of the comics, I absolutely love the theme. Co-written by Mark Millar (Kick-Ass, Marvel's Civil War, Swamp Thing) There are so many cool characters, locations, and concepts from the comics in this game, and if you're are not familiar with the stories, you get to play the coolest "new" IP/license! I am so glad they did not use the Sylvester Stallone story and characters. Instead of fighting that stupid Rico guy from the 90s movie, your final battle is Judge Death. Instead of being helped by Rob Schneider's dopey character, they bring in Judge Judy, his psychic partner (as an add-a-ball)! They really focused on bringing the comic world to life in this game.
One of the best "moments" is activating the deadlworld. The lighting and sound all helps you focus in on that mode. Another feel-good is when you really get in rhythm during the Judge battles and start knocking them down! Unique modes, none of them are the same: the reactor's capture balls, the tank shots, the sniper in the tower, and one of the best is "public nuisance", an Elvis impersonator that you need to shoot the lit drop targets to get him off stage. Fun mini modes: the rocket shot from the left ball launcher, the judge stand-ups with the subway shot (which doubles as the super jackpot for super-ball).
I can play this game for hours . This is the first game I played that made me realize that pinball is my favorite hobby :)