Over: MM. Fun, but not $8k fun;
Under: RBION, WPT, Dr Who, SG, WoF... You might get 4 of them for the cost of a MM...

Over: CV and IJ One is pretty to look at the other just ok and neither is fun to play.
Under: Popeye and LW3 Both are fun and crowd favs. Not sure why they are so low and IJ is so high. Both beat the pants of IJ and it's horrid gameplay. Loose and sloppy is how I would describe that game.

Over: CV, MM, AFM...
Under: HS2, HS, Monopoly

I have no idea why CV is so highly priced. I mean, it's pretty simple. Don't get my wrong, it's a fun game. But not $7000 fun. It's definitely not as deep or as fun as Addams Family, Funhouse, etc IMO. AFM is the same way as CV. MM, not so much, but still a good runner up. YMMV of course.

Couldn't have said it better myself!

Overrated: Tron, CV
Underrated: NGG

Interesting to see JP get a lot if under rated votes, but I've had one and LAH, the LAH is far more fun than JP.

Any new opinions on this? I'm looking for a 2nd pin to go with my HS2. I think I have narrowed it down to somewhere from the DMD era. I of course like good gameplay, but like the whole package to be there; artwork, sound, gameplay; something you just want to keep playing. I love playing my Getaway, and don't see ever selling it. I am by far not a great player, so something fun and cool is what I'm looking for. I like how the DMDs add to the game. Thoughts on this now?

It's really different for every person. I see a lot of MMs and TAFs in the list for overrated, but I would definitely get $8k of enjoyment out of a MM(r). And a HEP restored TAF is the last pin I plan to purchase. Waiting on that for last for obvious reasons.

My only real advice is to go play a LOT of pins from this era and find one you think you'd like to be able to play every day. There aren't really any machines from this era I *dislike*, but there's a number I'm neutral on. Some of my favorites besides TAF/MM are AFM, WH20, Road Show, Fish Tales, STTNG, Congo, Corvette, and Banzai Run. But there's a huge variety of game feels there, you'd have to play them to decide.

Overrated = Whatever is the most recently released pin at the time
Underrated = Dr. Who